Feedback can be positive or critical and happens as a result of something one person does or says that another person hears, sees, or experiences. Because of this, it’s based on a past action, which is an important distinction from coaching. In addition, feedback is given from the feedback-giver’s perspective; it’s a story or statement about what they observed and the result that it had.
Coaching, on the other hand, is focused on the future. It happens within a relationship where one person (the learner) is communicating with another person (the coach) who has more expertise in an area. It’s centered on helping the learner to improve and achieve their goals.
While feedback is about statements or stories, coaching is characterised by questions. A good coach doesn’t tell the learner what to do; she asks open-ended questions to help the learner discover the answer or explore alternative solutions.
Feedback can and should be given often and should be done as soon as possible after a behaviour has occurred (this goes for both critical and positive feedback). Positive feedback can be given in front of others if it feels appropriate, while critical feedback should always be delivered privately.
Coaching on the other hand is not as time-sensitive and requires a bit more time to get into an in-depth conversation between the coach and the learner. One-on-ones are a great place for managers to use coaching techniques. Coaching also works best when the learner has some experience with the skills they’re being coached on. If a task is completely new to someone, that person needs feedback, as well as specific direction and instruction in how to do the task.
What’s the Main Point?
Feedback is about helping someone get better at what they’re doing right now. It’s usually about something that’s already happened-good or bad-and is meant to help them meet expectations or fix something quickly.
Coaching is more about helping someone grow for the future. It’s about building skills, confidence, or figuring out where they want to go in their career.
When Does It Happen?
Feedback happens as soon as possible after something happens – like after a meeting, a project, or a customer interaction.
Coaching is more of an ongoing thing. It’s usually planned ahead, like during regular one-on-ones, and is more about the bigger picture.
How Does It Work?
Feedback is direct. You tell someone what you noticed, how it went, and what could be better. It’s more about sharing your perspective.
Coaching is more about asking questions and listening. Instead of telling someone what to do, you help them figure it out for themselves by guiding the conversation.
Who’s Involved?
Feedback can come from anyone – boss to employee, peer to peer, or even the other way around.
Coaching usually happens when someone has more experience or knowledge in a certain area and is helping someone else learn or grow. It works best when there’s trust and the person being coached is open to learning.
What’s the Result?
Feedback helps people make quick changes or keep doing what’s working.
Coaching helps people develop over time, become more independent, and tackle bigger challenges.
When Should You Use Each?
| Use feedback when… | Use coaching when… |
| You need to correct a mistake or reinforce something done well | Someone wants to develop new skills or take on bigger challenges |
| You want to talk about something specific that just happened | You’re supporting someone’s long-term growth or career goals |
| It’s about day-to-day stuff like being on time or handling a customer | Someone is figuring out how to handle tricky situations or grow as a leader |
- Give feedback to help people know what’s expected and to fix things quickly.
- Use coaching when you want to help someone grow, solve problems, or plan for the future.
Feedback is about what happened and what to do next time. Coaching is about helping someone figure out where they’re going and how to get there. Both are important, but they work best when you use them at the right time.
Want to know more about supporting and growing your teams? Let’s talk. Click here to contact me